- Research article
- Open Access
Nuclear and mitochondrial data reveal different evolutionary processes in the Lake Tanganyika cichlid genus Tropheus
BMC Evolutionary Biology volume 7, Article number: 137 (2007)
Cichlid fishes are notorious for their wealth of intra- and interspecific colour pattern diversity. In Lake Tanganyika, the endemic genus Tropheus represents the most impressive example for geographic variation in the pattern and hue of integument colouration, but the taxonomy of the over 100 mostly allopatric colour morphs remains to a large degree unresolved. Previous studies of mitochondrial DNA sequence data revealed polyphyly of the six nominally described species and complex phylogeographic patterns influenced by lake level fluctuations and population admixture, and suggested the parallel evolution of similar colour patterns in divergent evolutionary lineages. A gene tree of a rapidly radiating group may be subject to incomplete and stochastic lineage sorting, and to overcome this problem we used multi-locus, nuclear AFLP data in comparison with mtDNA sequences to study diversification, migration and introgression in Tropheus colour morphs in Lake Tanganyika.
Significant incongruence between phylogenetic reconstructions from mitochondrial and AFLP data suggested incomplete sorting of mitochondrial haplotypes as well as frequent introgression between differentiated lineages. In contrast to the mitochondrial phylogeny, the AFLP phenogram was largely congruent with species classifications, colour pattern similarities, and in many cases also with the current geographic distribution of populations, and did not produce evidence of convergent colour pattern evolution. Homoplasy in the AFLP data was used to identify populations that were strongly affected by introgression.
Different evolutionary processes were distinguished by the combination of mitochondrial and AFLP data. Mitochondrial phylogeographic patterns retained signals of large-scale migration events triggered by historical, major lake level fluctuations, whereas AFLP data indicated genetic cohesion among local groups of populations resulting from secondary contact of adjacent populations in the course of the more frequently occurring, minor lake level fluctuations. There was no support for the parallel evolution of similar colour patterns in the AFLP data. Genetic signatures of introgression and hybridisation detected in several populations suggest that lake level fluctuations drove the stunning diversification of Tropheus morphs not only through population fragmentation, but also by promoting hybridisation between differentiated morphs in secondary contact.
Incongruence among gene trees is a widespread phenomenon in phylogenetic studies of recently and rapidly radiating species [1–7]. Mitochondrial DNA markers have several evolutionary properties that make them suitable for phylogenetic and phylogeographic studies, but inferences within and between closely related species can be misled by introgression and incomplete lineage sorting [2, 8–10]. In recent years, the amplified fragment length polymorphism technique (AFLP, ) has found application in evolutionary studies to resolve phylogenies both at the intraspecific population level as well as between several million year old lineages [12–16]. In cichlids and other rapidly diversifying taxa, where speciation events often precede fixation of alleles within a species (e.g. ), the combined analysis of numerous AFLP markers recently has been shown to overcome the problems of incomplete sorting of alleles between speciation events [12, 17–21].
The tribe Tropheini comprises a highly diverse assemblage of cichlid fishes endemic to Lake Tanganyika that radiated from a riverine ancestor and evolved into the most abundant group in the rocky littoral zone [22, 23]. As a sister group to the Tropheini, the remaining "modern haplochromines" (sensu ) also originated in Lake Tanganyika and later dispersed through the rivers of eastern Africa to colonise the younger lake basins of Lakes Malawi and Victoria . The genus Tropheus represents the most impressive example for the phenomenon of geographic variation in body colour pattern in Lake Tanganyika's cichlid species, and over 100 mostly allopatric colour variants are recognised [24, 25]. Due to their diversity, Tropheus represent a promising system for studies of colour pattern evolution, and for the same reason, specimens of the genus have become extremely popular among aquarists. So far, six nominal species have been described based on morphological characters (T. moorii BOULENGER, 1898; T. annectens BOULENGER, 1900; T. duboisi MARLIER, 1959; T. brichardi NELISSEN and THYS VAN DEN AUDENAERDE, 1975; T. kasabae NELISSEN, 1977 and T. polli AXELROD, 1977; ). However, there are no scientific data on the distribution of the species around the lake, and many Tropheus populations from different regions of the lake cannot be unequivocally identified to species . Due to the uncertainties in the species-level taxonomy of the genus and the high level of colour pattern diversity on small geographic scales, populations are generally identified by their locality rather than by species (e.g. ), and this practice is also adopted in the present work. The popularity of Tropheus recently prompted attempts to improve the taxonomic coverage of the genus, which were presented in the popular literature but have not been validated by scientific studies. For example, in addition to the scientifically described nominal species, Konings  suggested five taxa (T. sp. "black", T. sp. "red", T. sp. "Ikola", T. sp. "Mpimbwe") and proposed assignments of populations to the different species based on phenotypic traits such as body shape and coloration. Schupke  described more than 100 Tropheus populations and arranged them into 13 colour lineages.
The evolution and phylogeographic history of the genus was investigated in four studies that were based on mitochondrial sequence data and revealed highly complex patterns of lineage distribution [27–30]. One concurrent finding of these studies was the paraphyletic status of the genus, as T. duboisi represents a distinct unit, which is not in a sister group relationship to the remaining species of the genus Tropheus. Sturmbauer et al.  defined 12 mitochondrial lineages based on a phylogenetic reconstruction using a parsimony method implemented in TCS , which have evolved in the course of two major radiations about 700–945 Ka and 399–540 Ka. Both diversification events could be correlated to extreme changes of lake level, and a lowstand of Lake Tanganyika in the recent past (11–17 Ka; ) might have shaped the present distribution of lineages.
Lake level fluctuations displace benthic populations and entail cycles of population admixture and isolation, and indeed, several Tropheus populations comprise a mixture of different mitochondrial lineages, indicating introgression during secondary admixis of formerly differentiated populations. Mitochondrial haplotype sharing across opposite shorelines further testifies that lineages were able to cross the lake along the ridges between the lake basins during periods of low lake level . Despite the historically unstable population distribution along the shore, Tropheus populations display high levels of genetic structure across very short geographic distances in both mitochondrial and nuclear markers ( and unpublished data). Gradual among-population differences in colour pattern generally increase with geographic distance between populations, and major habitat barriers (like sandy bays) often separate phenotypically highly distinct morphs (see Fig. 1 for a map of Lake Tanganyika and Tropheus colour morphs). However, populations displaying similar colour patterns are not always closely related in terms of mtDNA phylogenetic reconstructions, which suggests introgression among lineages and convergent evolution of colour patterns in the genus. Only recently, hybridisation has been proposed as an important factor for the generation of diversity in animals , and recent phylogenetic studies showed that introgression has occurred between distinct lineages within the cichlid species flocks and even might have given rise to hybrid speciation in some cases [6, 18, 34–36]. Some of the colour pattern diversity in Tropheus may well be due to the introgression events indicated by mitochondrial data.
To overcome the limitations of phylogenetic inference from a single gene, both AFLP and mtDNA sequence data were collected from Tropheus populations around Lake Tanganyika. Mitochondrial and nuclear-multilocus tree reconstructions were tested for consistency, and hypotheses based on previous mtDNA studies, such as introgression patterns and convergent evolution of certain colour patterns, were evaluated with respect to the AFLP data. The different information provided by the two marker systems was used to address different processes affecting the evolutionary history and current phylogeography, such as large-scale migration and hybridisation between colour morphs. Due to the uncertainty of species-level taxonomy in Tropheus, we apply Harrison's  definition of hybridisation as "the interbreeding of individuals from two populations, or groups of populations, which are distinguishable on the basis of one or more heritable characters". Finally, the molecular data were compared to current species assignments and to the suggested classifications of Konings  and Schupke .
Mitochondrial sequence relationships
The 117 samples included in this study represent 9 of the 12 previously defined mitochondrial lineages based on parsimony network clusters reconstructed in the program TCS (Fig. 2; ). The topologies of the trees derived by Bayesian inference (Fig. 2, 117 samples) and a NJ analysis (117 samples; [see Additional file 1]) were consistent with the NJ topology inferred in a comprehensive analysis of 462 Tropheus samples . Differences between tree topologies concern nodes with little support from posterior probability and bootstrap values. Fifty-nine of the samples presented here were not included in the dataset of Sturmbauer et al.  and a description of their positions in the phylogenetic reconstructions is presented as supplementary information [see Additional file 2].
As previously observed (e.g. [27, 28]), the mitochondrial phylogenetic reconstruction of Tropheus populations was in several instances inconsistent with the geographic distribution of populations on the one hand and with colour pattern similarities among populations on the other hand. Figure 2 shows that there is little agreement between mitochondrial sequence relationships and suggested species assignments  and colour lineage classifications .
AFLP genotype clusters
AFLP data were obtained with ten primer combinations and consisted of 914 fragments (146 constant, 687 parsimony informative and 81 parsimony-uninformative sites). The resulting tree topology was markedly different from the mtDNA-based reconstruction. Shimodeira-Hasegawa  LRT found the difference of 904 likelihood units between mtDNA and AFLP topologies to be significant (P < 0.05).
Unlike the mitochondrial sequence phylogeny, the AFLP phenogram revealed clusters of phenotypically and, in part, geographically close populations (Fig. 1, Fig. 3). Four major clades could be identified: The basal clade (AFLP 1) comprised a heterogeneous group of samples from geographically quite distant localities, whose populations have been assigned to T. brichardi (northern basin: Nyanza Lac, Bulombora, Kabimba and Halembe, southern basin: Ulwile Island, Namansi and Nvuna Island). Clade AFLP 2 contained T. polli sampled from Ikola at the eastern shore of the central basin as well as T. "Kongole" from Kavala Island at the southwestern shoreline of the northern basin, which phenotypically closely resemble T. polli. Clade AFLP 3 comprised the colour morphs displaying a dark body colour with a conspicuous yellow or red band or with blotches – e.g. the popular T. "Kaiser" and "Kirschfleck" – as well as the newly described morph "red belly" from Mabilibili with a less contrast rich colour pattern. Within this clade, the populations from Kiriza, Mboko, Bemba and Rutunga in the north, and from Ikola and the Kungwe mountain range in the east were grouped in two sister sub-clades consistent with their geographic distribution. Finally, clade AFLP 4 unites the T. moorii populations from the southern basin of the lake with Tropheus from Mpimbwe splitting at the base. Within AFLP 4, the T. moorii populations were grouped according to their geographic range and phenotypic conformity (Fig. 1), but statistical support for these subclades was weak. In more detail, the red-coloured morphs from Chisanze to Livua grouped together in one subclade. The colour morphs with a yellow blotch on their body side (Kasakalawe to Kala) were grouped as a subclade sister to the colour morphs displaying a bluish body colour (Katukula to Chaitika). The population in Katoto is apparently an admixture of both morphs . "Yellowish" morphs from Lufubu, Kabeyeye and Inangu were placed in the "bluish" subclade, whereas the yellow Ilangi morph was resolved as sister group to the clade that unites "bluish" and "yellow-blotch" morphs with more "red-brownish" populations from Wapembe and Namansi and from Kalya further north.
Samples from the same population always belonged to the same major AFLP clade even when they were not grouped next to each other, whereas they were often distributed across several mtDNA lineages. Suggested species assignments  and colour lineage classifications  by and large agreed with AFLP clades (Fig. 3; see Discussion).
Signals of introgression and hybridisation: AFLP homoplasy excess test and mitochondrial relationships
Hybrid genotypes contain AFLP-fragments from both parental clades, which appear as homoplasies and reduce bootstrap support for the parental clades . Hence, removal of hybrid taxa from the phylogenetic analysis will increase bootstrap values for the parental clades significantly beyond any changes in bootstrap support induced by removal of any other non-hybrid taxa. Such changes in bootstrap support caused by the removal of any random clades could, for example, be due to retained ancestral polymorphism in the data set. The procedure of removing various different clades from the analysis therefore serves to distinguish signals of hybridization from signals of ancestral polymorphism. Note that ancestral polymorphism, introgression involving several clades as well as homoplastic mutations will prevent bootstrap support values for a parental clade from reaching 100% even when the hybrid taxon is removed from the data set. Furthermore, it is theoretically possible that a "hybrid" signal in the AFLP data is solely due to retained ancestral polymorphism, when drift was much weaker in some populations than in others.
We removed each of the 51 population samples at a time, and calculated bootstrap support for 15 nodes in the taxon reduced data set. Additionally, in two instances, several populations were removed at once (samples of the four yellow coloured morphs from Ilangi, Inangu, Kabeyeye and Lufubu; and samples of T. polli from Ikola North together with T. "Kongole" from Kavala Island). The homoplasy tests identified a number of potentially introgressed populations, which is in line with the interpretation of the published mtDNA based phylogeographic data claiming that very few populations experienced longer periods of independent evolutionary history. This made reconstruction of possible hybrid parents very difficult in most cases, as parental populations of hybrid taxa were probably often themselves affected by introgression. Figure 4 shows boxplot diagrams of the distribution of bootstrap values obtained from the 53 taxon-reduced runs for selected examples, which were interpreted as possible hybrid origin of or substantial introgression into the taxon whose removal caused the significant increase in bootstrap support of a node. See Figure 3 for positions of the nodes mentioned in the following text. The geographic distribution, mitochondrial lineage assignment and phenotype of the populations involved in the here described examples of introgression is given as supplementary information [see Additional file 2].
Removal of the Tropheus "red belly" individuals resulted in a rise of the bootstrap value at node 8a2 from 418 to 948 (Fig. 3 and 4A), which strengthens support for nuclear genetic cohesion of this – phenotypically plausible – group. Our data suggest that the "red bellies" represent a hybrid morph with one parent in the AFLP-3 clade – likely a T. "Kirschfleck" –, but the AFLP data failed to pinpoint the second candidate parent clade. Removal of the yellow coloured morphs sampled near the Lufubu estuary (Fig. 4B) increased the bootstrap values at node 1 ("bluish" + "yellow-blotched", from 154 to 666), node 1a ("bluish", from 14 to 240), node 2 (from 219 to 776) and node 4a ("red", from 266 to 427), and slightly raised support at node 1b ("yellow-blotched", from 518 to 621). These homoplasy signals together with mitochondrial haplotype composition of the "yellow" morphs [see Additional file 2] suggest ancient introgression between the "red" and "bluish" morphs. The removal of individuals from Livua (Fig. 4C) resulted in a rise of bootstrap values at nodes 4b ("red" morphs, from 588 to 885) and 5 (from 205 to 554), and removal of Chisanze samples from the AFLP dataset (Fig. 4D) had strong effects on the bootstrap values of node 4a ("red", from 266 to 453), node 4b ("red" without Livua, from 588 to 800) and node 3 (306 to 557). Both cases are suggestive of introgression between distinct lineages. The population at Katoto, which is located near a bay that separates "bluish"and "yellow-blotched" morphs, has been assumed to originate from an admixture of the two morphs, since it displays an intermediate colour pattern and contains haplotypes from both sides of the bay . In the AFLP analysis, the removal of the two samples from Katoto caused a slight increase of the bootstrap value at node 1b (the "yellow-blotched" clade) from 518 to 665 (Fig. 4E), which was beyond the bootstrap value fluctuations caused by removal of other taxa. Although the signal is weak, it is consistent with introgression of the "yellow-blotched" morph into the Katoto population.
There was no significant increase in bootstrap support for nodes 5a, 8, 8a, 10 and 11 in any of the taxon-reduced runs.
Our results demonstrate a high degree of incongruence between mtDNA derived and nuclear based phylogenetic reconstructions, suggesting incomplete lineage sorting and introgression in the course of the evolution of the genus Tropheus. Alternatively, sex-biased dispersal behaviour could have contributed to the observed disparities. However, congruent genetic structure was detected in mitochondrial haplotype and nuclear microsatellite data in a population genetic analysis (unpublished data), which indicates that, at least on small geographic scales, both sexes show concordant dispersal behaviour. Incomplete lineage sorting is not uncommon in the rapidly diversifying lacustrine cichlids of East Africa, and was, for example, demonstrated in phylogenetic studies on Lake Victoria cichlids  and the Mbuna cichlids of Lake Malawi [12, 40–42]. The importance of incomplete lineage sorting and/or hybridisation has also been discussed for Lake Malawi non-Mbuna cichlids  and the Lake Tanganyika cichlid species assemblage [9, 44], in particular with respect to the tribes Eretmodini , Lamprologini [6, 36, 45, 46] and Perissodini . Given the rapidity of the mitochondrial lineage diversification in the genus Tropheus in combination with population displacements and admixtures triggered by lake level fluctuations , it is reasonable to expect signals of both incomplete lineage sorting and introgression in the genetic data.
The phylogeographic distribution of the mitochondrial haplotypes of Tropheus populations is highly complex. Distribution ranges of mitochondrial lineages overlap in several regions of the lake and distinct mtDNA lineages often comprise populations from geographically very distant localities and with distinct phenotypes (Fig. 2; see also ). Additionally, mitochondrial sequence relationships are much at odds with suggested species delineations in the scientific as well as in the aquarist literature  and with a proposed classification of the genus into lineages based on colour pattern similarities (; Fig. 2). In contrast, the phenogram based on AFLP data (Fig. 3) is largely congruent with species classifications (e.g. T. brichardi in clade AFLP 1, T. polli in clade AFLP 2), colour pattern similarities (AFLP 3 and sub-clades in AFLP 4), and in many cases also with the current geographic distribution of populations (sub-clades in AFLP 3; AFLP 4 and sub-clades therein; Fig. 3). Besides the recently discovered "red belly", the morphs included in clade AFLP 3 were classified as T. sp. "black" and T. sp. "ikola" (consisting of the "Kaiser" morph from Ikola) by Konings , and Schupke  elaborated an even more fine-scale subdivision of this clade into four colour lineages. Mitochondrial sequences of these morphs were resolved in different lineages, and suggested convergent evolution of the conspicuous colour pattern. In contrast, the AFLP data indicate monophyletic ancestry of the geographically disjunct, but phenotypically similar populations around Bemba in northern Lake Tanganyika, and along the Kungwe mountain range in the central lake basin, and furthermore signal genetic cohesion between the similarly coloured populations within each region (see Fig. 1 and 3). The separate taxonomic placement of the "Kaiser" morph from Ikola outside T. sp. "black" is not supported by our data.
Within clade AFLP 4, there was no bootstrap support for the relationships between subclades. This lack of AFLP-based resolution may reflect a high frequency of introgression among the populations inhabiting the shallow southern tip of Lake Tanganyika. Here, even rather minor lake level fluctuations must have displaced littoral populations, which were forced to follow the shifting shoreline, and thus induced admixture of several previously isolated populations. Likewise, the populations from the shallow northern tip of the lake (samples from Kiriza, Mboko, Bemba and Rutunga in AFLP 3) were not resolved by locality within their clade, probably due to the same reason. Additionally, sampling sites along the southern shoreline were more densely distributed than in other regions, and signals of introgression between neighbouring populations were therefore picked up more readily. Nevertheless, although significant bootstrap support is lacking, the grouping of the southern populations within clade AFLP 4 is consistent with the geographic distribution and the phenotypic similarities, and by and large identifies the "red" morphs, the "bluish" morphs and the "yellow-blotched" morphs as differentiated units with genetic connectivity within colour morphs. Still, the distinction of T. sp. "red" from T. moorii  is not fully supported by our data.
In contrast to the continuous geographic distribution of clade AFLP 4 containing the southern populations, the three other clades have a fragmented distribution along the lakeshore, which follows from the disjunct distributions of the species joined into these clades . The processes leading to the patchy distributions of these species remain puzzling, but may be consequences of colonisation waves following lake level fluctuations and competitive interactions between differentiated colour morphs and species .
Despite the disparities between mtDNA and AFLP data, both marker types supply valuable and complementary phylogenetic and phylogeographic information. Whereas AFLP data for the first time demonstrated the genetic cohesion of some Tropheus taxa, the mitochondrial data provided details about the colonisation history of the genus Tropheus and revealed multiple waves of diversification and dispersal (see also ). For example, mitochondrial data give evidence of migration across the lake or into distant populations on the same lakeshore, where the introgressed mtDNA haplotypes occasionally persisted and sometimes even drifted to high frequencies . In the multi-locus AFLP data, the signal of individual migration events was lost through recombination, whereas the genetic continuity between neighboring populations and the common ancestry of phenotypically discernible clades becomes visible. Large-scale migrations are probably associated with isolated periods of severe lake level lowstands . Similarly, the gene flow between adjacent populations along a stretch of shoreline indicated by AFLP data is likely to occur in a punctuated fashion, when occasional drops of the lake level impose secondary contact, rather than by ongoing dispersal, as populations have been shown to be genetically differentiated at distances of less than 10 km .
In recent studies of cichlids, hybridisation has been advanced as an additional pathway for the generation of novel taxa [6, 7, 18, 35, 46], and hybrids have been observed in nature [e.g. [36, 48, 49]]. Usually, hybrids are first recognised by their intermediate colour patterns or body shape, but in the case of Tropheus, the great wealth of intergradient colour morphs complicates a phenotypic detection of potential hybrids. The AFLP data revealed numerous potential cases of hybridisation and introgression between morphs, which may have given rise to novel morphs in some instances. Positive colour-assortative mating between highly distinct Tropheus morphs in secondary contact has recently been demonstrated in a population consisting of artificially admixed morphs, but reproductive isolation was weak between less distinct morphs , and similar results were obtained in laboratory mate choice experiments (Egger et al. unpublished data). Under natural conditions, genetic evidence for the admixture of morphs displaying distinct colour patterns exists in the population of Katoto, while examples for the maintenance of a reproductive barrier between very distinct phenotypes is found in the sympatric T. sp. "black" and T. polli from Ikola North, and in the sympatric occurrence of "Kirschfleck"-morphs with T. polli and T. brichardi in different regions of the lake. Hybridisation between very distinct morphs could also have been promoted by turbid water conditions such as in river estuaries or caused by strong rainfalls, like it is known for Lake Victoria cichlids . There is some evidence in our data that the yellow morphs near the Lufubu River estuary are strongly influenced by high levels of introgression from the neighboring "bluish" and "red" morphs or even may have originated from hybridisation between these morphs. In laboratory experiments, "bluish" and "red" morphs mate assortatively (Egger et al. unpublished data), but variables such as visibility and resource distribution may have considerable impact on mate choice in the field.
We conclude that the combination of mitochondrial and AFLP data provides valuable information on different processes affecting the evolutionary history of Tropheus. Mitochondrial phylogeographic patterns retained signals of large-scale migration events triggered by major lake level fluctuations, whereas the genetic cohesion among local groups of populations indicated by AFLP data results from gene flow between adjacent populations brought about by relatively frequent minor lake level fluctuations. Introgression and hybridisation between differentiated populations, morphs and species was evident in both types of molecular data, and we suggest that lake level fluctuations drove the stunning diversification of Tropheus morphs not only through population fragmentation, but also through hybridisation between differentiated morphs in secondary contact.
Taxon sampling and DNA extraction
We obtained genetic data from 117 Tropheus individuals originating from 51 localities, covering almost the entire shoreline of Lake Tanganyika. Denser sampling along the southern shoreline reflects the political situation in the countries bordering the lake (see Fig. 1). Fish were either collected in the field or purchased from ornamental fish importers. Samples and sampling localities are given in Figure 1 and a supplementary table [see Additional file 3]. DNA was isolated from ethanol-preserved fin-clips or white muscle tissue using proteinase K digestion followed by a high-salt extraction technique . DNA concentration was measured using the Fluoroskan Ascent FL-System. All samples were adjusted to a concentration of 60 ng/μl.
mtDNA sequence analyses
Previous studies of mitochondrial phylogeography in Tropheus by Sturmbauer and Meyer , Sturmbauer et al. , Baric et al.  and Sturmbauer et al.  have accumulated 5' partial control region sequence data for more than 450 Tropheus samples. Fifty-eight of these published sequences were used in this study [see Additional file 3], and additional sequences from 59 individuals were obtained as follows. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR), purification of PCR products, and sequencing followed the protocol described in Duftner et al. . The primers used for PCR and sequencing were L-Pro-F  and TDK-D . DNA fragments were purified with Sephadex™ G-50 (Amersham Biosciences) following the manufacturer's instruction and visualized on a 3130 × l capillary sequencer (Applied Biosystems).
DNA sequences were aligned by eye using the Sequence Navigator software (ver. 1.0.1 Applied Biosystems). The alignment comprised 367 bp, with 243 constant sites, 27 parsimony-uninformative characters and 97 parsimony-informative characters. Empirical base frequencies in this data set were A = 0.3540, C = 0.2206, G = 0.1308, T = 0.2946. Phylogenetic relationships among the 117 samples used in the present study were estimated by a Bayesian method of phylogenetic inference using MrBayes (ver. 3.0b4 ), applying the substitution model HKY, as suggested by Modeltest (ver. 3.06 ), with T. duboisi as outgroup. Posterior probabilities were obtained from a 4,000,000 generation Metropolis-coupled Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation (ten chains; chain temperature, 0.2) with parameters estimated from the data set. Trees were sampled every hundred generations and the first 20,000 trees were excluded as burn-in to allow likelihood values to reach stationary. The resulting tree (Fig. 2) serves to represent the mitochondrial structure and diversity of Tropheus populations as resolved in Sturmbauer et al. . Additionally, NJ was run in PAUP* (ver. 4.0b10, ) under the HKY+I+G  substitution model as estimated on the data by Modeltest (invariable sites, 0.47, gamma shape parameter, 0.90), with T. duboisi as outgroup.
Previous work  combined mtDNA control region sequences of 462 Tropheus samples into a neighbour joining (NJ) tree, and classified samples into mitochondrial lineages corresponding to unconnected networks resolved by a phylogenetic reconstruction using a parsimony method implemented in TCS (ver. 1.13 ). The phylogenetic analysis of the 117 samples included in the present work was conducted in order to enable a comparison between AFLP data and the documented mitochondrial diversity of Tropheus, and to illustrate references to the mtDNA phylogeography published in .
AFLP genotypes were obtained from the same 117 individuals as used for the mitochondrial analysis, except for four samples from Zongwe and Livua, which had to be replaced by alternative samples from the same locations, because the DNA previously used for mtDNA sequencing was of insufficient quality for AFLP genotyping. Restriction digestion of 60 ng of genomic DNA was performed in a total volume of 50 μl using 0.5 μl Mse I (10 units/μl, New England Biolabs), 0.25 μl EcoR I (200 units/μl, New England Biolabs), 5 μl enzyme buffer (10×), 0.5 μl BSA (100×) and high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) water, and incubated for three hours at 37°C. For adaptor ligation, 1 μl EcoR I-adaptor (50 pmol/μl), 1 μl Mse I-adaptor (5 pmol/μl), 1 μl T4 ligase buffer, 0.2 μl T4 DNA ligase and 6.8 μl HPLC water were added to the product of the restriction digestion and incubated over night at 22°C. The ligation products were subsequently diluted to 180 μl using HPLC water. The preselective amplifications contained 3 μl of the diluted ligation product, 0.4 μl each of EcoR I and Mse I preselective primers (10 μM), 2 μl 10× MgCl2 buffer, 2 μl 10× dNTP mix (10 μM) and 0.6 μl Taq DNA polymerase (5 units/μl, BioTherm™) in a final volume of 20 μl. The preselective primers consisted of the adaptor primer sequence with a single selective nucleotide at the 3' end (EcoRI-pre: A, MseI-pre: C). The preselective PCR used the following temperature profile: 2 min at 72°C followed by 20 cycles of 20 sec at 94°C, 30 sec at 56°C, and 2 min at 72°C, then a holding step at 60°C for 30 min. PCR products were diluted 1:10 for selective amplification. For selective amplifications we used the following ten primer combinations: EcoR I-ACA/Mse I-CAA, EcoR I-ACA/Mse I-CAG, EcoR I-ACA/Mse I-CAC, EcoR I-ACA/Mse I-CAT, EcoR I-ACT/Mse I-CAT, EcoR I-ACT/Mse I-CAA, EcoR I-ACT/Mse I-CAG, EcoR I-ACT/Mse I-CAC, EcoR I-ACG/Mse I-CTG, EcoR I-ACT/Mse I-CTG. The PCR cocktail contained 1 μl of the diluted preselective PCR product, 6.3 μl HPLC water, 0.8 μl 10× dNTP mix (10 μM), 1 μl 10× MgCl2 buffer, 0.4 μl Taq DNA polymerase (5 units/μl; BioTherm™), 1 μl selective Mse I primer (10 μM) and 1 μl selective EcoR I primer (1 μM) labeled with the fluorescent dye FAM. The temperature profile for the selective PCR was as follows: 2 min at 94°C followed by 10 cycles with 20 sec at 94°C, 30 sec at annealing temperature, which decreased in each cycle by 1°C from 65°C to 56°C, and 2 min at 72°C. The PCR continued for 25 cycles with 20 sec at 94°C, 30 sec at 56°C, and 2 min at 72°C, followed by a holding step at 60°C for 30 min. All amplifications were performed on a GeneAmp PCR system 9700 (Applied Biosystems). Selective amplification products were visualized on an ABI 3130 × l automated sequencer (Applied Biosystems) along with an internal size standard (GeneScan-500 ROX, Applied Biosystems).
Raw fragment data were analyzed using Genemapper (ver. 3.7, Applied Biosystems). Automated analysis with a fluorescent threshold value set to 40 units yielded 2694 fragments, but the results were compromised by the fact that the restriction and ligation reactions had been carried out in two batches, as ten DNA samples became available only when the first batch of samples had already been processed. We detected a small number of fragments that were fixed in one batch of samples but missing from the other, which resulted in the clustering of those individuals that had been processed together. The second restriction and ligation batch also contained 6 replicate samples that had already been processed in the first set of reactions, which allowed us to identify and exclude the artifact, batch-specific fragments. Consequently, the dataset does not include bands with fixed presence in one batch of samples and fixed absence in the other batch. Furthermore, we found automated scoring problematic with respect to fragments that show gradual intensity differences between samples, as in such cases, any detection threshold must be arbitrary. Consequently, presence and absence of peaks were scored by eye in the Genemapper software within a range of 100–500 bp, and only distinct, major fragments were considered and assembled as a binary (1/0) matrix. In a few cases, fragments were scored as missing data when character states could not be determined unambiguously. Manual scoring yielded a lower number of marker bands than automated scoring, but data quality was substantially improved by this approach. Manually scored genotypes of replicates matched to a level of 96%. The resulting data matrix consisted of 914 fragments in 117 samples.
The program Treecon (ver. 1.3b ) was used to construct a NJ tree from a pairwise distance matrix . As with mtDNA analyses, three samples of T. duboisi were used as outgroup taxa. Bootstrap values from 1000 pseudo-replicates were calculated to assess support for the reconstructed tree topology. There is no explicit consensus in the literature with regard to the most appropriate tree reconstruction method for AFLP data. With the present data set, the use of a different distance estimator  for NJ analysis and tree reconstruction by parsimony criteria yielded the same major clades as the here presented tree.
Testing for homoplasy excess
A tree-based method  was performed to test for homoplasy excess introduced by hybridisation and introgression. Theoretically, the inclusion of a hybrid taxon into a multi-locus phylogeny introduces homoplasy with clades that include the hybrid parents. Removal of the hybrid taxon should therefore decrease the amount of homoplasy in the dataset and increase bootstrap support for clades containing hybrid parents or their descendents. Conversely, removal of non-hybrid taxa should not affect the bootstrap support of other nodes. One population sample at a time was removed from the data, and bootstrap support for 15 nodes in the AFLP tree (see Fig. 3) was computed. This procedure yielded a distribution of bootstrap values for each of the 15 nodes, which was analysed by the method of boxplots. Values more than 3 interquartile ranges away from the box were considered significant outliers.
Dowling TE, de Marais BD: Evolutionary significance of introgressive hybridization in cyprinid fishes. Nature. 1993, 362: 444-446.
Moore WS: Inferring phylogenies from mtDNA variation: mitochondrial-gene trees versus nuclear-gene trees. Evolution. 1995, 49: 718-726.
Barrier M, Baldwin BG, Robichaux RH, Purugganan MD: Interspecific hybrid ancestry of a plant adaptive radiation: alloploidy of the Hawaian silversword alliance (Asteraceae) inferred from floral homeotic gene duplication. Mol Biol Evol. 1999, 16: 1105-1113.
Shaw KL: Conflict between nuclear and mitochondrial DNA phylogenies of a recent species radiation: what mitochondrial DNA reveals and conceals about modes of speciation in Hawaiian crickets. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2002, 99: 16122-16127.
Beltrán M, Jiggins CD, Bull V, Linares M, Mallet J, McMillan WO, Bermingham E: Phylogenetic Discordance at the Species Boundary: Comparative Gene Genealogies Among Rapidly Radiating Heliconius Butterflies. Mol Biol Evol. 2002, 19: 2176-2190.
Salzburger W, Baric S, Sturmbauer C: Speciation via introgressive hybridization in East African cichlids?. Mol Ecol. 2002, 11: 619-625.
Seehausen O: Hybridization and adaptive radiation. Trends Ecol Evol. 2004, 19: 198-207.
Page RDM: Extracting species trees from complex gene trees: reconciled trees and vertebrate phylogeny. Mol Phyl Evol. 2002, 14 (1): 89-106.
Takahashi K, Terai Y, Nishida M, Okada N: Phylogenetic relationships and ancient incomplete lineage sorting among cichlid fishes in Lake Tanganyika as revealed by analysis of the insertion of retrotransposons. Mol Biol Evol. 2001, 18: 2057-2066.
McCracken KG, Sorenson MD: Is Homoplasy or Lineage Sorting the Source of Incongruent mtDNA and Nuclear Gene Trees in the Stiff-Tailed Ducks (Nomonyx-Oxyura)?. Syst Biol. 2005, 54: 35-55.
Vos P, Hogers R, Bleeker M, Reijans M, van de Lee T, Hornes M, Friters A, Pot J, Paleman J, Kuiper M, Zabeau M: AFLP: a new technique for DNA fingerprinting. Nucl Acids Res. 1995, 23: 4407-4414.
Albertson RC, Markert JA, Danley PD, Kocher TD: Phylogeny of a rapidly evolving clade: The cichlid fishes of Lake Malawi, East Africa. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1999, 96: 5107-5110.
Giannasi N, Thorpe RS, Malhotra A: The use of amplified fragment length polymorphism in determining species trees at fine taxonomic levels: analysis of a medically important snake, Trimeresurus albolabris. Mol Ecol. 2001, 10: 419-426.
Parsons YM, Shaw KL: Species boundaries and genetic diversity among Hawaiian crickets of the genus Laupala identified using amplified fragment length polymorphism. Mol Ecol. 2001, 10: 1765-1772.
Schneider MV, Beukeboom LW, Driessen G, Lapchin L, Bernstein C, Van Alphen JJM: Geographical distribution and genetic relatedness of sympatrical thelytokous and arrhenotokous populations of the parasitoid Venturia canescens (Hymenoptera). J Evol Biol. 2002, 15: 191-200.
Kidd MR, Kidd CE, Kocher TD: Axes of differentiation in the bower-building cichlids of Lake Malawi. Mol Ecol. 2006, 15: 459-478.
Allender CJ, Seehausen O, Knight ME, Turner GF, Maclean N: Divergent selection during speciation of Lake Malawi cichlid fishes inferred from parallel radiations in nuptial coloration. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2003, 100: 14074-14079.
Schliewen UK, Klee B: Reticulate sympatric speciation in Cameroonian crater lake cichlids. Front Zool. 2004, 1: 5-
Sullivan JP, Lavoué S, Arnegard ME, Hopkins CD: AFLPs resolve phylogeny and reveal mitochondrial introgression within a species flock of African electric fish (Mormyroidea: Teleostei). Evolution. 2004, 58: 825-841.
Mendelson TC, Simons JN: AFLPs resolve cytonuclear discordance and increase resolution among barcheek darters (Percidae: Etheostoma: Catonotus). Mol Phyl Evol. 2006, 41 (2): 445-453.
Mendelson TC, Shaw KL: The use of AFLP markers in surveys of arthropod diversity. Methods in Enzymology v. 395: Molecular Evolution: Producing the Biochemical Data. Edited by: Zimmer EA, Roalson E. 2005, San Diego: Academic Press, 161-175.
Sturmbauer C, Hainz U, Baric S, Verheyen E, Salzburger W: Evolution of the tribe Tropheini from Lake Tanganyika: synchronized explosive speciation producing multiple evolutionary parallelism. Hydrobiologia. 2003, 500: 51-64.
Salzburger W, Mack T, Verheyen E, Meyer A: Out of Tanganyika: Genesis, explosive speciation, key-innovations and phylogeography of the haplochromine cichlid fishes. BMC Evol Biol. 2005, 5: 17-
Konings A: Tanganyika cichlids in their natural habitat. 1998, El Paso: Cichlid Press
Schupke P: African Cichlids II: Tanganyika I: Tropheus. 2003, Aqualog, A. C. S Gmbh
Snoeks J, Rüber L, Verheyen E: The Tanganyika problem: comments on the taxonomy and distribution patterns of its cichlid fauna. Archiv für Hydrobiologie, Beiheft Ergebnisse der Limnologie. 1994, 44: 355-372.
Sturmbauer C, Koblmüller S, Sefc KM, Duftner N: Phylogeographic history of the genus Tropheus, a lineage of rock-dwelling cichlid fishes endemic to Lake Tanganyika. Hydrobiologia. 2005, 542: 335-366.
Sturmbauer C, Meyer A: Genetic divergence, speciation and morphological stasis in a lineage of African cichlid fishes. Nature. 1992, 358: 578-581.
Baric S, Salzburger W, Sturmbauer C: Phylogeography and evolution of the Tanganyikan cichlid genus Tropheus based uponmitochondrial DNA sequences. J Mol Evol. 2003, 56: 54-68.
Sturmbauer C, Verheyen E, Rüber L, Meyer A: Phylogeographic patterns in populations of cichlid fishes from rock habitats in Lake Tanganyika. Molecular Systematics of Fishes. Edited by: Kocher TD, Stepien CA. 1997, San Diego: Academic Press, 97-111.
Clement M, Posada D, Crandall KA: TCS: a computer program to estimate gene genealogies. Mol Ecol. 2000, 9: 1657-1659.
Gasse F, Lédée V, Massault M, Fontes J-C: Water-level fluctuations of Lake Tanganyika in phase with oceanic changes during the last glaciation and deglaciation. Nature. 1989, 342: 57-59.
Sefc KM, Baric S, Salzburger W, Sturmbauer C: Species-specific population structure in rock-specialized sympatric cichlid species in Lake Tanganyika, East Africa. J Mol Evol. 2007, 64: 33-49.
Rüber L, Meyer A, Sturmbauer C, Verheyen E: Population structure in two sympatric species of the Lake Tanganyika cichlid tribe Eretmodini: evidence for introgression. Mol Ecol. 2001, 10: 1207-1225.
Smith PF, Konings A, Kornfield I: Hybrid origin of a cichlid population in Lake Malawi: implications for genetic variation and species diversity. Mol Ecol. 2003, 12: 2497-2504.
Koblmüller S, Duftner N, Sefc KM, Aibara M, Stipacek M, Blanc M, Egger B, Sturmbauer C: Reticulate phylogeny of gastropod-shell-breeding cichlids from Lake Tanganyika – the result of repeated introgressive hybridization. BMC Evol Biol. 2007, 7: 7-
Harrison RG: Hybrids and hybrid zones: historical perspective. Hybrid Zones and the Evolutionary Process. Edited by: Harrison RG. 2003, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 3-12.
Shimodeira H, Hasegawa M: Multiple comparisons of log-likelihoods with applications to phylogenetic inference. Mol Biol Evol. 1999, 16: 1114-1116.
Nagl S, Tichy H, Meyer WE, Takahata N, Klein J: Persistence of neutral polymorphisms in Lake Victoria cichlid fish. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1998, 95: 14238-14243.
Moran P, Kornfield I: Retention of ancestral polymorphism in the mbuna species flock (Pisces: Cichlidae) of Lake Malawi. Mol Biol Evol. 1993, 10: 1015-1029.
Moran P, Kornfield I: Were population bottlenecks associated with radiation of the mbuna species flock (Teleostei: Cichlidae) of Lake Malawi?. Mol Biol Evol. 1995, 12: 1085-1093.
Parker A, Kornfield I: Evolution of the mitochondrial DNA control region in the mbuna (Cichlidae) species flock of Lake Malawi, East Africa. J Mol Evol. 1997, 45: 70-83.
Takahashi K, Nishida M, Yuma M, Okada N: Retroposition of the AFC family of SINEs (Short Interspersed Repetitive Elements) before and during the adaptive radiation of cichlid fishes in Lake Malawi and related inferences about phylogeny. J Mol Evol. 2001, 53: 496-507.
Takahashi K, Terai Y, Nishida M, Okada N: A novel family of short interspersed elements (SINEs) from cichlids: the patterns of insertions of SINEs at orthologous loci support the proposed monophyly of four major groups of cichlid fishes in Lake Tanganyika. Mol Biol Evol. 1998, 15: 391-407.
Sturmbauer C, Verheyen E, Meyer A: Mitochondrial phylogeny of the Lamprologini, the major substrate spawning lineage of cichlid fishes from Lake Tanganyika in Eastern Africa. Mol Biol Evol. 1994, 11: 691-703.
Schelly R, Salzburger W, Koblmüller S, Duftner N, Sturmbauer C: Phylogenetic relationships of the lamprologine cichlid genus Lepidiolamprologus (Teleostei: Perciformes) based on mitochondrial and nuclear sequences, suggesting introgressive hybridization. Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2006, 38: 426-438.
Koblmüller S, Egger B, Sturmbauer C, Sefc KM: Evolutionary history of Lake Tanganyika's scale-eating cichlids fishes. Mol Phylogenet Evol. 44 (3): 1295-1305.
Seehausen O, van Alphen JJM, Witte F: Cichlid fish diversity threatened by eutrophication that curbs sexual selection. Science. 1997, 277: 1808-1811.
Stauffer JR, Bowers NJ, Kocher TD, McKaye KR: Evidence of hybridisation between Cynotilapia afra and Pseudotropheus zebra (Telestoei: Cichlidae) following an intralacrustine translocation in Lake Malawi. Copeia. 1996, 1: 203-208.
Salzburger W, Niederstätter H, Brandstätter A, Berger B, Parson W, Snoeks J, Sturmbauer C: Colour-assortative mating in the cichlid species Tropheus moorii from Lake Tanganyika, East Africa. Proc Biol Sci. 2006, 273 (1584): 257-266.
Miller SA, Dykes DD, Polesky HF: A simple salting out procedure from human nucleated cells. Nucl Acids Res. 1988, 16: 1215-
Duftner N, Koblmüller S, Sturmbauer C: Evolutionary relationships of the Limnochromini, a tribe of benthic deep water cichlid fishes endemic to Lake Tanganyika, East Africa. J Mol Evol. 2005, 60: 277-289.
Meyer A, Morrissey JM, Schartl M: Recurrent origin of sexually a selected trait in Xiphophorus fishes inferred from a molecular phylogeny. Nature. 1994, 368: 539-541.
Lee W-J, Conroy J, Howell WH, Kocher TD: Structure and evolution of teleost mitochondrial control regions. J Mol Evol. 1995, 41: 54-66.
Huelsenbeck JP, Ronquist F: MrBayes: Bayesian inference of phylogenetic trees. Bioinformatics. 2001, 17: 754-755.
Posada D, Crandall KA: MODELTEST: testing the model of DNA substitution. Bioinformatics. 1998, 14: 817-818.
Swofford DL: PAUP* – Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony and other methods, version 4.0. 2003, Sunderland: Sinauer
Hasegawa M, Kishino H, Yano T: Dating of the human-ape splitting by a molecular clock of mitochondrial DNA. J Mol Evol. 1985, 22: 160-174.
Van de Peer Y, de Wachter R: TREECON for Windows: a software package for the construction and drawing of evolutionary trees for the Microsoft Windows environment. Comput Appl Biosci. 1994, 10: 569-570.
Nei M, Li WH: Mathematical model for studying genetic variation in terms of restriction endonucleases. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1979, 76: 5269-5273.
Link W, Dixkens C, Singh M, Schwall M, Melchinger AE: Genetic diversity in European and Mediterranean faba bean germ plasm revealed by RAPDmarkers. Theor Appl Genet. 1995, 90: 27-32.
Afrika Cichliden. [http://www.afrika-cichliden.de]
We thank the Fisheries Research Division of the Department of Research and Specialist Services, Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Fisheries, Zambia, and in particular their team at the Mpulungu Station, for continuous hospitality and support with sampling and field work.
The work was funded by the Austrian Science Foundation (grant P17380). BE acknowledges field travel support by the Karl-Franzens-University of Graz.
All authors were involved in sampling. The study was designed by KMS. AFLP data were collected and analysed by BE. Mitochondrial sequence data were collected and analysed by SK. The manuscript was drafted by BE and KMS with contributions by SK and CS. All authors read and approved the final version.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Egger, B., Koblmüller, S., Sturmbauer, C. et al. Nuclear and mitochondrial data reveal different evolutionary processes in the Lake Tanganyika cichlid genus Tropheus. BMC Evol Biol 7, 137 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2148-7-137
- Bootstrap Support
- Colour Pattern
- Colour Morph
- Mitochondrial Haplotype
- Incomplete Lineage Sorting