- Research article
- Open Access
Recurrent camouflaged invasions and dispersal of an Asian freshwater gastropod in tropical Africa
BMC Evolutionary Biology volume 15, Article number: 33 (2015)
Non-indigenous taxa currently represent a large fraction of the species and biomass of freshwater ecosystems. The accumulation of invasive taxa in combination with other stressors in these ecosystems may alter the habitats to which native taxa are adapted, which could elicit evolutionary changes in native populations and their ecological interactions. Assessing ecological and evolutionary consequences of invasions simultaneously may therefore be the most effective approach to study taxa with complex invasion histories. Here we apply such an integrated approach to the cerithioid gastropod Melanoides tuberculata, a model system in invasion biology.
Molecular phylogenetics and ancestral range reconstructions allowed us to identify several independent Asian invasions in Lakes Malawi and Tanganyika, the Congo River, Nigeria and Cameroon. Some invasive M. tuberculata populations display much variation in shell morphology, and overlap in morphospace with M. tuberculata populations native to Africa. Experiments confirmed great ecophenotyic plasticity in some invasive populations, which, in combination with the overlap in disparity with native populations, masks invaders and their dispersal through Africa. Finally, the results of geographic modeling indicate that cryptic M. tuberculata invasions occurred primarily in densely populated areas.
We reveal the continental nature of invasions of Asian M. tuberculata to Africa. Several of the affected ecosystems have high endemicity in Cerithioidea: Lake Tanganyika has an unparalleled diversity in freshwater cerithioids (>10 endemic genera) and the Congo Basin and Lake Malawi are home to the two largest endemic species clusters of Melanoides in Africa (~12 and ~8 species, respectively). Cerithioids perform ecologically important functions in the benthic ecosystems of African freshwaters, but invaders and ecosystem change pose risks to their native diversity. We draw suggestions for more effective conservation strategies from our integrated approach.
Introductions of non-indigenous species are among the least reversible of human impacts on the world’s ecosystems . They decrease global biodiversity via the extirpation of native faunas and biotic homogenization, and regularly cause considerable economic loss [2-5]. The world’s freshwater ecosystems are heavily affected by biological invasions, and non-indigenous taxa constitute a large fraction of the species, individuals, and biomass in such ecosystems. In North America and Europe at least 1,176 freshwater invaders have been recorded [1,6], but for tropical Africa knowledge is more limited. Nevertheless, African examples exist in a wide variety of taxa, including plants, invertebrates and vertebrates, and some of these cases illustrate the deep and far-reaching ecological impacts of invaders across various ecosystem levels. Perhaps the most renowned and ecologically devastating example from Afrotropical freshwaters comes from Lake Victoria, where the Nile Perch (Lates niloticus) was introduced . This invasive piscivore drove many of the 500+ endemic cichlid fishes to extinction , and, aided by other stressors, including eutrophication and blooms of the invasive water hyacinth Eichhornia, caused rapid and wholesale ecosystem change in the lake . Although the introduction of the Nile Perch can be considered economically lucrative, it increased economic stratification and because the fish is locally unaffordable  it perhaps did not increase availability of animal protein to the local population.
The case of Lake Victoria substantiates (1) that freshwater biodiversity regularly faces the effects of several anthropogenic stressors at once [11,12], (2) that the effects of invasions can be particularly devastating in isolated, eco-insular systems such as the African Great Lakes [13,14], and (3) that biological invasions may drastically alter ecological and evolutionary patterns in ecosystems and their native biota [15,16]. Hence, the case underscores the relevance of approaches that investigate invasion dynamics and effects simultaneously at various biological levels (e.g. invasive populations, community effects, emerging continental patterns), especially for taxa with complex invasion histories.
Here we study African populations of the cerithioid gastropod Melanoides tuberculata (Müller, 1774), a model system in invasive biology . The species is polyploidy and has a mixed reproductive system with parthenogenetic and sexual reproduction . Sexual reproduction is rare, resulting in the persistence of entire genotypes for many generations [17,18]. Because of the predominant parthenogenetic reproduction, local populations of a genetic clone usually display limited morphological variation . As a result, previous authors [18-22] have characterized clonal populations as morphs, and have assigned three-letter codes to these morphs.
Indigenous strains of M. tuberculata occur on the African continent but around the 1980s, an Asian lineage of M. tuberculata (LMI morphs) invaded Lake Malawi . This invasion remained long unnoticed, although the invasive morphs have a characteristic morphology, because morphological variation within and between indigenous M. tuberculata morphs is poorly understood, so that native lineages camouflage the invader’s presence. Consequently, variation in other indigenous African populations of M. tuberculata may likewise obscure the presence of invaders, which hampers our understanding of colonization history and therewith appropriate monitoring and conservation strategies. Moreover, the invader became fully established in Lake Malawi , and recent changes in ecological interactions have resulted in marked responses in the benthic community . The camouflaged invasion and its ecological and evolutionary consequences in Lake Malawi urge further investigations of the invasion history of M. tuberculata on the African continent. Because M. tuberculata has a notorious invasion history in the Neotropics [17,20], and because knowledge on its African invasions is comparatively limited, we investigate the species with an integrated approach.
First, we produce a backbone phylogeny that allows assessing phylogeographic patterns, evolutionary history and therewith molecular screening of new Melanoides collections spanning the East African Rift and surroundings for potential invaders. Morphological studies of wild-collected and lab-bred specimens were conducted to obtain insights into the variability of shell morphology in M. tuberculata, and combined with the phylogeny into genotype-phenotype relationships. Integration of morphological and molecular data is particularly important because some gastropods have been misperceived as invasive , and because phenotypic plasticity and genetic variation influence dispersal capabilities and, hence, ‘invasiveness’ [15,26]. Moreover, a better understanding of shell morphology would facilitate morphological identifications of invasive strains in the field. Using geographical modeling we also investigate how humans and anthropogenic stressors affect the invasion history of M. tuberculata in Africa. Finally, we discuss the implications of our findings to conservation strategies for African freshwater habitats.
Sampling and experimental procedures
We collected material from the Congo River, its tributaries and the Lake Edward region of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), from Lake Tanganyika in Burundi, Lake Malawi and the Shire River in Malawi, Lake Kivu in Rwanda, and Lakes Kyoga and Edward, and the Victorian Nile River in Uganda (all between 2006 and 2012), and supplemented this material with previously published samples (Table 1; Figure 1). Material collected for phylogenetic studies was preserved in 80% EtOH. Specimens of one Melanoides population (n = 40; 09-032; CD05-CD06) from Kisangani (DRC) were maintained and bred in laboratory tanks after which the shell morphology of wild-caught parents, lab-bred F1 offspring, and other populations of M. tuberculata were compared. For the experiment we used a 100 l tank that had been set up before for common garden experiments with endemic gastropods from Lake Malawi (seeded with Malawi sand and water; see ). Water conditions reflected those of Lake Malawi (pH ~8.0; T = ~26°C), but with a higher amount of dissolved oxygen (~6.0 mL/L instead of 3.5-4.0 mL/L), and a higher electrical conductivity (increased bicarbonate hardness; ~1,800 μS/cm instead of ~260 μS/cm in the lake) to prevent shell corrosion. These values are somewhat dissimilar from those measured in waters in the Kisangani area (09-032; pH ~6.0-7.0; T = ~24°C, conductivity ~70 μS/cm).
Melanoides specimens were identified based on shell morphology using the relevant literature [30,31]. Shell morphology was studied directly and after cleaning with bleach. Morphological comparisons were performed independently by B.V.B. and C.C. using a modified version (1 extra trait, some additional trait values) of the categorical shell-morphological character scoring system of Facon et al. . Modifications allow coding the sampled endemic Melanoides species of the DRC for comparison. As mentioned, the predominantly parthenogenetic reproduction of M. tuberculata usually results in limited intrapopulation variation in shell morphology . Discrete morphs can hence be recognized and the morphological scoring system is considered to be generally robust for delimiting parthenogenetic lineages of M. tuberculata, although closely related morphs occasionally display strikingly different shell features [20,21]. Characters with multiple states were converted to arithmetic means and morphological scores were converted into a distance matrix that was ordinated with non-metric multidimensional scaling (nmMDS) in three dimensions following the guidelines of Van Bocxlaer and Schultheiß . We used the packages MASS version 7.3-27  and vegan version 2.0-10  in R version 3.0.1  for nmMDS.
Genomic DNA was isolated using the CTAB protocol . Two gene markers were used: (1) mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI), and the (2) mitochondrial large ribosomal subunit (mtLSU rRNA or 16S). DNA, specimen and image vouchers of newly sequenced material (49 specimens) were deposited at the Justus Liebig University’s Systematics and Biodiversity collection (UGSB); data on other specimens (59 COI and 37 16S sequences) was retrieved from NCBI GenBank (Table 1).
COI sequences were obtained utilizing the forward primer LCO1490 , and the reverse primers HCO2198  or COX-B7R . For amplification of partial 16S DNA we used the forward and reverse primers (16Sar-L and 16Sbr-H) from Palumbi et al. . PCR cycling conditions are specified in Additional file 1: Table S1. Bidirectional DNA sequencing was performed on a 16-capillary 3730xl Genetic Analyzer (Applied Biosystems). New sequences were deposited in GenBank (Table 1). The first basepairs (bp) behind the 3’ end of each primer were difficult to read. We therefore trimmed each sequence, leaving a 580 bp-long overlapping COI fragment and a 451-455 bp-long 16S fragment. The protein-coding COI sequences were unambiguously aligned using ClustalW implemented in BioEdit 18.104.22.168 . We aligned 16S fragments using the multiple sequence alignment program PRANK  with empirical base frequencies, the Tamura-Nei substitution model and default settings for gap penalties. Ambiguously aligned sites (posterior probability of the obtained structure state ≤0.8) were excluded from subsequent analyses. Inclusion of unknown states for shorter 16S fragments obtained from GenBank caused alignment problems and the deletion of 70 bp, many of which were informative. Therefore, we decided to drop these shorter-fragment sequences from our dataset (n = 21; Table 1), resulting in a 452 bp long 16S alignment for 63 haplotypes.
No substantial substitutional saturation was found in the COI and 16S datasets upon testing with DAMBE version 5.2.73 . The final dataset (COI + 16S) contained a total of 79 unique sequences (including one of Thiara scabra, four of Tarebia granifera, and the outgroup taxa Hydrobia glyca and Lavigeria grandis; see Table 1). Substitution models were examined for individual partitions with jModelTest 0.1.1  using corrected Akaike and Bayesian Information Criteria (AICc and BIC, respectively). The best supported substitution model for the COI dataset was HKY + I + G (AICc and BIC) and for the 16S alignment GTR + G (AICc) or HKY (+ I) + G (BIC; same support with or without invariant sites). The concatenated dataset was analyzed in BEAST version 1.7.4  using a Yule speciation process, a total of 40,000,000 generations (with sampling each 1,000th generation), and a burn-in of 20,001. Independent phylogenetic analyses were performed using strict and uncorrelated lognormal relaxed clock models (with 1.0 as relative rate). Effective sample size (ESS) values of all major parameters within the BEAST analyses were visualized and checked in Tracer version 1.5.0 . These checks demonstrated that the ESS values for ‘prior’ and ‘posterior’ were unacceptably low when the GTR + G model was used for the 16S partition, which may indicate that the model was overparameterized. Hence, we decided to use the still well-supported but less complex HKY + I + G model for each partition in the concatenated dataset which produced good ESS values (>200) for all parameters. Bayes Factor (BF) analysis was performed in Tracer and likelihood values based on 1,000 bootstrap replicates were evaluated to select the appropriate clock model (following criteria of Kass and Raftery  and Suchard et al. ). To examine potential conflicts among the COI and 16S partitions each dataset was also analyzed individually in BEAST following the conditions described above (e.g. HKY + I + G model).
To examine invasions and to get a better insight into the geographic distribution of the ingroup taxa we performed ancestral range reconstructions with the concatenated COI + 16S dataset. For transparency and to avoid circularity we only included actual occurrences of the terminal taxa in the dataset, regardless of whether the material is known to be invasive in the area of occurrence. For example, specimens from the Neotropics are coded as American, even though the specimens represent well-documented Asian invasions [17,20]. Analyses were performed in R using the packages ape 3.1-4  and geiger 2.0.3 , and independently with Lagrange version 20130526 . For the first, regions were coded and states were reconstructed using maximum likelihood estimation and marginal reconstruction. For Lagrange a presence-absence matrix was created and combined with the phylogeny in the Lagrange configurator (http://www.reelab.net/lagrange/configurator/index) to create the input file, which was analyzed using default settings.
Anthropogenic influences on the colonization history of invasive M. tuberculata in Africa were assessed with spatial modeling. We used human population size as a proxy of the variety of anthropogenic effects, e.g. human-mediated dispersal and anthropogenic changes in habitats (pollution, use of natural resources, and climate change), that humans have on natural environments in a particular region. Specifically, we investigated the null hypothesis that localities with recorded invasions represent a random sample with respect to human population. We used NASA SEDAC’s gridded population of the World data (GPWv3; count data, estimates for 2010)  with a spatial resolution of ~21 km2, and extracted data for sub-Saharan Africa (as defined in ) as an estimator of anthropogenic stressors. We compared human population counts for cells where invasive Melanoides specimens are recorded to the counts for all grid cells (n = 988,224) and assessed the probability of observed patterns in two ways. First, we divided all grid cells in two groups; the first group contains all cells where human population counts are smaller than the minimum count in grid cells with invasive gastropods; the second group has all counts higher than this minimum. We then calculated the statistical chance for the observed number of invasions to occur in the grid cells where they were observed assuming human population density is not affecting invasions. Second, we drew 10,000 random samples of grid cells from sub-Saharan Africa, each with a size equal to the number of grid cells with observed invasions and summed the human population counts of these grid cells. With these random samples we built a frequency distribution against which we plotted the summed human population counts from grid cells with invasions. Spatial modeling was performed in R 3.0.1 using the packages raster 2.2-31 , rgdal 0.9-1 , dismo 0.9-3  and MASS.
The nominal, endemic Melanoides species of Lake Malawi have been aggregated by some authors [22,54] into a ‘M. polymorpha complex’, even though distinct morphs can be discerned in the modern [31,55] and fossil faunas of Lake Malawi . We have not altered previous assignments of specimens in GenBank, but consider the traditional species valid until a formal taxonomic revision demonstrates otherwise.
Phylogenetic analyses of the concatenated COI + 16S dataset (Figure 2) resulted in overall highly similar topologies to those in single fragment phylogenies (Figure 3), despite substantial differences in the sampling for both genes (Table 1). Analyses of BF revealed that the fit of uncorrelated lognormal relaxed clock models to our datasets was consistently better than that of strict clock approaches, and hence uniform rates of sequence evolution along the phylogeny were rejected. Ancestral range reconstructions in R and using Lagrange resulted in almost identical results; the first method was used for visualization; results of the second method are displayed in Additional file 2: Table S2.
Phylogenetic inference revealed a split between two clades of Melanoides species (Figures 2 and 3), both of which have occurrences on Africa and Asia. One of these clades (clade 1) contains predominantly endemic taxa from Lakes Malawi and Mweru and the Congo Basin, a sub-clade of Asian M. tuberculata, and Tarebia granifera; the other clade (clade 2) contains taxa endemic to the Congo Basin, other morphs of M. tuberculata and Thiara scabra (Figure 2). Our phylogeny hence indicates that Melanoides is paraphyletic, as Thiara scabra and Tarebia granifera cluster within Melanoides clades (Figure 2). Moreover, Melanoides tuberculata, and interestingly also the African endemic Melanoides species were found to be polyphyletic.
Phylogenetic reconstruction (Figure 2) reveals the occurrence of an invasive Asian morph of M. tuberculata in the Kisangani area (DRC) that is closely related to the LMI morphs from Lake Malawi (with a basal Bayesian Posterior Probability [BPP] support of 1.00). The invasive nature of this clade is well-supported by the ancestral range reconstruction of clade 5, certainly upon considering external evidence that American taxa within this clade represent historical Asian invasions. For consistency with the literature [17,20-22] we propose CDI as the three-letter code for this morph. Whereas some molecular variability exists in COI sequences of the LMI morphs from Lake Malawi, specimens from 5 populations of morph CDI have identical COI sequences. This CDI morph was found in 4 small rivers and swamps that discharge directly or indirectly to the Congo River and that encompass an area of 150 km2 (Additional file 3: Table S3). Another independent Asian invader has been sampled from Lake Tanganyika near Bujumbura (again with BPP = 1.00), and belongs to clade 2 (morph BIT; Figure 2). The invasive nature of this morph is again well-supported by ancestral range reconstructions. No Asian invasions were discovered thus far upon screening samples from the Nile drainage (Table 1). Ancestral range reconstructions for the entire ingroup suggested that an African origin is most likely.
Our phylogeny also revealed a close and strongly supported (BPP of 1.00) relationship between endemic Melanoides species from the Lower Congo River (downstream of Kisangani) and M. admirabilis from the Malagarasi River at the base of clade 2 (Figure 2).
Experimental and morphological data
Freshly collected Melanoides specimens from the Kisangani area have a very conspicuous dark-brown to black organic coating that masks most shell features. Upon bleaching, wild-caught individuals of morph CDI displayed more variability in shell features than did the LMI specimens from Lake Malawi as reported by Genner et al. , but lab-bred F1 specimens of morph CDI (n = 10) did not and resemble these LMI morphs strikingly (Figure 4, Table 2). A columellar band is usually present in LMI morphs  but it is often absent in specimens of morph CDI, and whereas axial ribs were reported to be absent in LMI, they are regularly present on juvenile whorls in CDI, albeit shallow (Table 2). All wild-caught individuals from population 09-032 that we examined lacked a columellar band and some had axial ribs (Table 2), but the band was faintly present on lab-bred F1 offspring of the population, which lacked axial sculpture, even on juvenile whorls (Figure 4F).
Ordination of morphological characters of native and invasive M. tuberculata in morphospace resulted in limited stress (8.99), which suggests a reliable ordination result. This result confirmed the observations mentioned above (Figure 5) and that the invasive BIT morph of M. tuberculata displays limited morphological variability in comparison to CDI and LMI morphs. On a continental scale, an overlap exists in morphological variation displayed by native and invasive M. tuberculata morphs (Figure 5), although some of the overlapping populations belong to deeply divergent clades (Figure 2).
Invasive lineages of Melanoides tuberculata were documented from 6 major localities in 5 countries (Ede, Nigeria; Eseka, Cameroon; Kinshasa, Kisangani, DR Congo; Bujumbura, Burundi; Monkey Bay/Cape Maclear, Malawi). At >500 people/km2, all these localities are densely populated. To be conservative, we divided grid cells into a group with more, and one with less than 100 people/km2. Adjusted to the spatial scale of the NASA human population grid this resulted in 76,391 and 911,833 cells in the first and second groups, respectively. The probability that the 6 localities with invasions represent a random sample with respect to human population density is very small (p = 2.13e-07). Comparing the sum of human population counts from the grid cells where invasions were observed (~257,000 people) to the frequency distribution of summed human population counts from randomly selected grid cells in sub-Saharan Africa resulted in 2 out of 10,000 simulations having counts higher than observed (Figure 6). Modeling results indicate that colonization was non-random and mainly in highly populated, and hence anthropogenically disturbed areas.
Reliability of phylogenetic data
Previous authors reported major incongruences between COI and 16S datasets, which prevented them from combining fragments into a concatenated analysis . Inclusion of more specimens, sequencing of longer 16S fragments, and the use of more advanced software for alignment and phylogenetic inference (see methods) removed this incongruence (Figures 2 and 3). The branching pattern of major clades and the documentation of some lineages as invasive were consistently recovered.
Phylogenetic patterns and biogeographic affinities
Phylogenetic analyses confirmed that Melanoides is paraphyletic and M. tuberculata polyphyletic , but interestingly, also the African endemic Melanoides species were revealed to be polyphyletic. Taxa endemic to Lakes Malawi and Mweru and the Lualaba River are part of clade 6, whereas others distributed more to the north in the Congo and Malagarasi Rivers belong to clade 4. As is the case for viviparids , the Congo system appears to play an important role in shaping biogeographical patterns for Melanoides species endemic to Africa, but additional sampling is required to evaluate similarities in the patterns of both taxa. Scrutinity is required to evaluate the position of M. imitatrix , and our phylogenetic reconstruction indicates a general need for more phylogenetic work (including nuclear markers) and taxonomic revisions of the genus Melanoides. Such revisions will ideally integrate molecular, conchological and anatomical analyses (see below).
Clades 1 and 2 of our phylogeny both contain Asian and African Melanoides species, with different degrees of molecular divergence (Figure 2). Earlier authors [18,22,54] have suggested that the genus Melanoides probably has an African origin, and ancestral range reconstructions confirm the likelihood of this scenario.
The close and highly supported phylogenetic relationship of M. admirabilis from Tanzania and endemic Melanoides species from the Congo River (Figures 1 and 2), i.e. between gastropods from rivers flowing into and out of Lake Tanganyika, indicate the historic connection of biological provinces east and west of this lake. Close affinities of Malagarasi and Congo River mollusks have been suggested before, e.g. for Potadomoides , but we present the first molecular evidence for this hypothesis. Molecular evidence supporting close phylogenetic relationships also exists in Congo and Malagarasi fishes [59-61]. However, fish faunas of Lake Tanganyika appear to have seeded the fauna of the lake’s tributaries and outflow to a larger extent  than appears the case for mollusks [62,63]. The pattern of basin endemism and close genealogical relationships between taxa that occupy the same drainage basin also suggests that the dispersal capacities of the native, endemic Melanoides species are more restricted than those of the invasive M. tuberculata morphs. Moreover, the phylogenetic relationships between freshwater biota in the Malagarasi River and the Congo River and the independent Melanoides invasions to Lake Malawi and Lake Tanganyika provide testimony that the ecosystems of long-lived African lakes are permeable, at least periodically, to more widespread biota; see .
Multiple invasions of M. tuberculata to Africa
Our phylogeny revealed that two deeply divergent clades of invasive, Asian M. tuberculata have contributed to the taxon’s continent-wide invasion of Africa (Figures 1 and 2). An invasive M. tuberculata morph (CDI) occurs in the Congo Basin, some 1,500 km away from the Malawi Basin, which is occupied by closely related invasive morphs (LMI1-4). These morphs are very closely related to two other morphs from Singapore (LSS, LSR) . We cannot exclude that morph CDI invaded the Kisangani area directly via intercontinental transport from Asia, but given that the single CDI haplotype is shared with LMI populations successful dispersal of LMI specimens over hydrographic boundaries is more likely (which is also supported by ancestral range reconstructions). Other African representatives of this invasive clade (clade 5) are morphs CAE from Cameroon (Eseka), morph ZAK from the DRC (Kinshasa), and (not shown) morph ND from Nigeria (Ede) . The molecular diversity in these African morphs suggests that multiple Asian representatives of clade 5 invaded Africa. Other morphs of clade 5 are invasive to America (morphs ARG from Argentina, TUM from Peru, BCI and USF from Florida, and M. amabilis from Martinique) and are genetically closely related to morphs with Asian origins, such as NAP from Singapore (Figure 2), morphs BAN and CHM from Thailand (Bangkok and Chiang-Mai, respectively; not shown), and morph ND from Indonesia (Lombok) [20,21]. These morphs (except for USF) are more distantly related to the CDI and LMI morphs, however. Another independent invasion occurred to Lake Tanganyika; this morph (BIT) is genetically nearly identical to morph USR from Singapore. Limited genetic diversity was observed within morphs CDI and BIT in comparison to that in invasive morphs from Lake Malawi, which suggests a single, potentially very recent, invasion for each of these morphs. Overall, our findings strongly indicate that multiple, independent invasions to Africa occurred, which may have resulted from increased aquarium trade [20,21]. Commercial activities with ornamental fish are reported for several of the localities where invasive M. tuberculata populations were recorded. More screening of other African Melanoides populations is required to fully document the geographic coverage of African invaders and the extent to which this coverage results from intercontinental introductions versus dispersal of invaders within Africa. Dispersal of LMI morphs to the north of Lake Malawi , to Lake Malombe , and further down the Shire River  suggests the morph will spread further through the Zambesi River system, and the occurrence of multiple CDI populations in various streams and ponds in the Kisangani area indicates that dispersal is ongoing there too.
Morphological variation and ecophenotypy
Interestingly, the Asian invasive lineages resemble eachother somewhat in overall shell morphology, although they belong to deeply divergent clades (Figure 5, compare e.g. Figure 4A-C with 4M; Table 2). Moreover, our results document an overlap in the morphological variation of native and invasive M. tuberculata. This overlap does not exist for the invasive and native M. tuberculata from Lake Malawi , which may explain why these invasive populations were detected early on. Observations in the Malawi Basin may have raised the expectancy that both groups can be separated easily. However, this expectancy does not hold on a continental scale; morphs belonging to clades 1 and 2 of our phylogeny (Figure 2) cannot be readily distinguished from one another using shell characters. The existence of morphological overlaps underscores the need for integrated molecular-morphological approaches to assess cryptic M. tuberculata invasions. Difficulties to identify genetic lineages based on morphological observations in the field currently hamper efforts aimed at conservation and they have contributed to the uncertain taxonomy of African Melanoides.
Unfortunately, some of the characters that were used to distinguish LMI morphs from the native LMN morphs of Lake Malawi (the presence of a columellar band and the absence of axial ribs; ) cannot be used to diagnose the closely related CDI morph from the Congo Basin. Further examination of LMI specimens from Lake Malawi confirmed that LMI morphs have become more variable in these features than originally reported (Table 2; see also [21,24]). Moreover, some LMI populations display gigantism (Figure 4R,S), which is mainly observed in LMN morphs following parasitic castration . However, the LMI specimens were not parasitized. A consistent morphological feature of CDI and LMI morphs is their very sharp apical angle, which is usually also observed in BIT specimens (Figure 4).
Although they have a genetic basis , shell features of the invasive M. tuberculata morphs are also subject to ecophenotypy. Differences in appearance relate partly to the organic layer that often covers shells, which may conceal differences between native and invasive M. tuberculata morphs (Table 2), and to actual shell morphology. The shell morphology of laboratory F1 offspring of morph CDI resembles that of some LMI morphs from Lake Malawi more closely than the variable set of morphological features displayed by their parents (Table 2, Figure 5). This observation of marked phenotypic plasticity is somewhat surprising given the clonal reproduction, and that morphs of M. tuberculata are known to have colonized habitats halfway across the globe without morphological changes (e.g. morph PCD in Martinique and Japan; ). Morphological variation in wild-collected morph CDI, despite the lack of genetic diversity in the mitochondrial markers studied, is considerably larger than in LMI morphs (Figure 6), which hence confirms the great plasticity observed in experiments. More puzzling is that CDI individuals from the wild are usually coated with a thick organic layer that obscures most shell features. Perhaps morphological variation is correlated with other fitness-affecting traits, rather than having a direct selective advantage.
Our data are consistent with the suggestion that phenotypic plasticity and genetic variation resulting from serial introductions enhance the dispersal capabilities of invasive taxa . However, various signals are observed: the LMI morphs that are spreading throughout the Malawi Basin display some genetic variability but seemingly limited plasticity whereas the opposite is observed for the CDI morph spreading in the Kisangani area (Figures 2 and 5). More research is required to elucidate this pattern and to look into the effects of plasticity and genetic variation on the success of invasion and dispersal. Although observed differences may relate to differences in ‘maturity’ of invasive populations and differences in the time of arrival to Africa, LMI morphs do not appear to have displayed elevated ecophenotyic plasticity before. Despite ecophenotypic variation, the apical angle appears to be a good diagnostic feature to select putatively invasive populations for molecular screening.
Ecosystem deterioration and invasiveness
Eutrophication and pollution are known to increase the biomass of some opportunistic benthic mollusks including M. tuberculata [31,64]. Melanoides primarily inhabits sandy substrates , and it is perhaps not surprising that the invasive M. tuberculata strains were observed in areas of high anthropogenic disturbance. The Burundian shorelines of Lake Tanganyika near Bujumbura, where morph BIT was sampled, are very densely populated by humans and heavily disturbed by sedimentation and eutrophication [65,66] (Figure 2). Most of the cerithioids endemic to Lake Tanganyika, like many other taxa including fishes and ostracodes, are adapted to rocky substrates and increased sedimentation strongly affects their communities [67-69]. Simultaneously, it may open ecological opportunities for invasive taxa that prefer soft substrates. In Lake Malawi the invaders first occurred on the shallow sandy shores of Cape Maclear/Monkey Bay in the south, where increased eutrophication and sedimentation likewise occur [21,70]. The small streams and swamps bordering agricultural land near the city of Kisangani that are inhabited by morph CDI are likewise heavily polluted (Additional file 3: Table S3).
Geographical modeling indicated that the localities where invasive Melanoides populations were recorded represent a selective set of highly populated areas rather than a random sample of localities in sub-Saharan Africa with respect to human population (Figure 6). Our observations hence indicate that ecosystem deterioration and anthropogenic stressors increase the susceptibility of ecosystems to colonization by invasive species. However, several factors may contribute to this pattern. Anthropogenic ecosystem deterioration may create ecological opportunities for invaders, but larger human population densities and changes in human behavior also increase the frequency with which alien propagules arrive. Another aspect that potentially contributed to invaders being mainly observed in densely populated areas could be that these areas provide more accessible sampling spots (e.g. because of better infrastructure), and hence, chances to detect invasions may be greater in densely populated areas. Nevertheless, we sampled many localities outside urban areas as well (Table 1), and, hence, we consider it unlikely that the observed patterns would be caused solely by the last factor.
Competitive interactions between invasive and native taxa may develop, certainly if the invader becomes established and migrates into previously unaffected environments. For example, in Lake Malawi negative spatial correlations are observed between the invasive LMI morphs and endemic Melanoides species, which suggests that competition may exist . In the Kisangani area invasive M. tuberculata occurs in micro-sympatry with endemic cerithioids (Potadoma), and in Lake Tanganyika in close vicinity to habitats occupied by endemic cerithioids (Tiphobia and Lavigeria), but existing data do not allow assessing whether resource competition between endemic taxa and the invader occurs in these localities. Beyond regional endemism in Potadoma [30,71] endemic Melanoides species occur in the Kisangani area, but micro-sympatry was not observed between native and invasive Melanoides in this region.
Cerithioid gastropods are ecologically important and often represent a significant component of benthic communities in terms of diversity, biomass and nutrient recycling [69,72]. Lake Tanganyika, the Congo River and Lake Malawi are home to the most diverse freshwater cerithioid communities of the African continent. In Lake Tanganyika >10 endemic cerithioid genera occur and the latter two freshwater bodies are hot spots for endemic richness in native Melanoides species (12-13 [excluding taxa endemic to Lake Mweru] and 8 endemic species, respectively, accounting combined for two-thirds of the native Melanoides on the African continent; [30,31]). Recurrent invasions of non-indigenous species may result in competitive interactions between invaders and the native fauna, and beyond the elimination of native biodiversity, hybridization and genetic homogenization are eminent concerns for endemic biodiversity [2,20,73].
Multiple anthropogenically-induced environmental stressors regularly interact with each other, which results in a faster deterioration of ecosystem stability than anticipated from individual stressors alone . The interactions between multiple stressors may directly or indirectly favor invasions and therewith biotic globalization . The occurrence of some ecosystem stressors may hence increase the likelihood that additional stressors arise. In the benthic environments of long-lived lakes increased runoff, sedimentation and eutrophication are powerful agents of change [9,12,69] that may create new ecospace and ecological opportunities for invaders to settle. Intensified surveys with the aim of detecting biological invasions are required and perhaps the monitoring of aquatic invasions should, beyond biodiversity hotspots, also focus on stressed sites, where greater ecological opportunities for opportunistic, eurytopic invaders may be present. Better insights into the interactions between invasive and native taxa are urgently needed in long-lived lakes. Once invaders get established their effects are very difficult or nearly impossible to remove from ecosystems, so our best chance to restrict their impact perhaps lies in integrated ecosystem conservation and attempts to diminish the frequency of biotic introductions.
Phylogenetic analyses of Melanoides specimens from sub-Saharan Africa with new methods removed previously existing inconsistencies between gene trees and documented the existence of multiple, independent invasions of Asian M. tuberculata to Africa. Our analyses furthermore indicated that M. tuberculata is polyphyletic, and the endemic, African Melanoides species as well, which highlights the need for more phylogenetic and systematic work. The areas that were invaded by Asian M. tuberculata all have high human population densities and anthropologically stressed aquatic ecosystems indicating that humans strongly determine colonization success. Affected ecosystems include long-lived Lakes Malawi and Tanganyika, and the Congo River, each of which has high endemic diversity in Cerithioidea. Morphological studies document overlaps in shell morphology between native and invasive M. tuberculata populations, and some invasive populations display great phenotypic plasticity, which appears to benefit their dispersal capabilities. The cryptic M. tuberculata invasions on a continental scale in Africa highlight the need for more concerted and integrated conservation strategies.
All DNA sequences used in this study are available from NCBI GenBank. Accession numbers are provided in Table 1.
Strayer DL. Alien species in fresh waters: ecological effects, interactions with other stressors, and prospects for the future. Freshwat Biol. 2010;55 Suppl 1:152–74.
Rahel FJ. Homogenization of freshwater faunas. Annu Rev Ecol Syst. 2002;33:291–315.
Lockwood JL, Hoopes MF, Marchetti MP. Invasion ecology. Malden: Blackwell Publishing Ltd; 2007.
Pejchar L, Mooney HA. Invasive species, ecosystem services and human well-being. Trends Ecol Evol. 2009;24(9):497–504.
Kolar CS, Lodge DM. Progress in invasion biology: predicting invaders. Trends Ecol Evol. 2001;16(4):199–204.
Gherardi F, Gollasch S, Minchin D, Olenin S, Panov VE. Alien invertebrates and fish in European inland waters. In: Drake JA, editor. Handbook of alien species in Europe. Dordrecht: Springer; 2009. p. 81–92.
Barel CDN, Dorit R, Greenwood PH, Fryer G, Hughes N, Jackson PBN, et al. Destruction of fisheries in Africa's lakes. Nature. 1985;315:19–20.
Witte F, Goldschmidt T, Wanink J, van Oijen M, Goudswaard K, Witte-Maas E, et al. The destruction of an endemic species flock: quantitative data on the decline of the haplochromine cichlids of Lake Victoria. Environ Biol Fishes. 1992;34:1–28.
Hecky RE, Mugidde R, Ramlal PS, Talbot MR, Kling GW. Multiple stressors cause rapid ecosystem change in Lake Victoria. Freshwat Biol. 2010;55 Suppl 1:19–42.
Pringle RM. The origins of the Nile Perch in Lake Victoria. Bioscience. 2005;55:780–7.
Donohue I, Petchey OL, Montoya JM, McNally L, Viana M, Healy K, et al. On the dimensionality of ecological stability. Ecol Lett. 2013;16:421–9.
Van Bocxlaer B, Albrecht C, Stauffer JR. Growing population and ecosystem change increase human schistosomiasis around Lake Malaŵi. Trends Parasitol. 2014;30(5):217–20.
Herben T. Species pool size and invasibility of island communities: a null model of sampling effects. Ecol Lett. 2005;8(9):909–17.
Davis MA. Biotic globalization: does competition from introduced species threaten biodiversity? Bioscience. 2003;53:481–9.
Lambrinos JG. How interactions between ecology and evolution influence contemporary invasion dynamics. Ecology. 2004;85(8):2061–70.
Shea K, Chesson P. Community ecology theory as a framework for biological invasions. Trends Ecol Evol. 2002;17(4):170–6.
Facon B, Pointier J-P, Jarne P, Sarda V, David P. High genetic variance in life-history strategies within invasive populations by way of multiple introductions. Curr Biol. 2008;18:363–7.
Samadi S, Mavárez J, Pointier J-P, Delay B, Jarne P. Microsatellite and morphological analysis of population structure in the parthenogenetic freshwater snail Melanoides tuberculata: insights into the creation of clonal variability. Mol Ecol. 1999;8:1141–53.
Pointier J-P. Conchological studies of Thiara (Melanoides) tuberculata (Mollusca: Gastropoda: Thiaridae) in the French West Indies. Walkerana. 1989;3:203–9.
Facon B, Pointier J-P, Glaubrecht M, Poux C, Jarne P, David P. A molecular phylogeography approach to biological invasions of the New World by parthenogenetic thiarid snails. Mol Ecol. 2003;12:3027–39.
Genner MJ, Michel E, Erpenbeck D, De Voogd N, Witte F, Pointier J-P. Camouflaged invasion of Lake Malawi by an Oriental gastropod. Mol Ecol. 2004;13:2135–41.
Sørensen LVG, Jørgensen A, Kristensen TK. Molecular diversity and phylogenetic relationships of the gastropod genus Melanoides in Lake Malawi. Afr Zool. 2005;40(2):179–91.
Genner MJ, Michel E, Todd JA. Resistance of an invasive gastropod to an indigenous trematode parasite in Lake Malawi. Biol Invasions. 2008;10:41–9.
Van Bocxlaer B, Albrecht C. Ecosystem change and establishment of an invasive snail alter gastropod communities in long-lived Lake Malawi. Hydrobiologia. 2015;744:307–16.
Pfenninger M, Weigand A, Bálint M, Klussmann-Kolb A. Misperceived invasion: the Lusitanian slug (Arion lusitanicus auct. non-Mabille or Arion vulgaris Moquin-Tandon 1855) is native to Central Europe. Evol Appl. 2014;7:702–13.
Knop E, Reusser N. Jack-of-all-trades: phenotypic plasticity facilitates the invasion of an alien slug species. Proc R Soc B Biol Sci. 2012;279:4668–76.
Gurdebeke PR, Van Bocxlaer B. Conchological differentiation in an ongoing radiation of Lanistes gastropods from ancient Lake Malawi: how adaptive is shell morphology? Geologica Belgica. 2013;16(1–2):118–9.
Hauffe T, Schultheiß R, Van Bocxlaer B, Prömmel K, Albrecht C. Environmental heterogeneity predicts species richness of freshwater mollusks in sub-Saharan Africa. Int J Earth Sci. 2014 (online early; doi 10.1007/s00531-014-1109-3)
Amante C, Eakins BW. ETOPO1 1 Arc-minute global relief model: procedures, data sources and analysis. NOAA Technical Memorandum NESDIS NGDC-24.ᅟ: Boulder, CO National Geophysical Data Center, NOAA; 2009. Doi: 10.7289/V5C8276M. Accessed November 2014.
Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory. Guide de terrain des gastéropodes d'eau douce africains 5: Afrique centrale. Charlottenlund, Denmark: Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory; 1982.
Brown DS. Freshwater snails of Africa and their medical importance. 2nd ed. London: Taylor and Francis; 1994.
Van Bocxlaer B, Schultheiß R. Comparison of morphometric techniques for shapes with few homologous landmarks based on machine-learning approaches to biological discrimination. Paleobiology. 2010;36(3):497–515.
Venables WN, Ripley BD. Modern applied statistics with S. 4th ed. New York: Springer; 2002.
Oksanen J, Blanchet FG, Kindt R, Legendre P, Minchin PR, O'Hara RB, et al. Vegan: Community Ecology Package. R package; version 2.0-10; 2013.
R Development Core Team. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Version 3.0.1. R Foundation for Statistical Computing; 2013.
Wilke T, Davis GM, Qui DC, Spear RC. Extreme mitochondrial sequence diversity in the intermediate schistosomiasis host Oncomelania hupensis: another case of ancestral polymorphism? Malacologia. 2006;48:143–57.
Folmer O, Black M, Hoeh W, Lutz R, Vrijenhoek R. DNA primers for amplification of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I from diverse metazoan invertebrates. Mol Mar Biol Biotechnol. 1994;3(5):294–9.
Schultheiß R, Wilke T, Jørgensen A, Albrecht C. The birth of an endemic species flock: demographic history of the Bellamya group (Gastropoda, Viviparidae) in Lake Malawi. Biol J Linn Soc. 2011;102:130–43.
Palumbi S, Martin A, Romano S, Mcmillian WO, Stice L, Grabowski G. The simple fool's guide to PCR. Honolulu: University of Hawaii; 1991.
Hall TA. BioEdit: a user-friendly biological sequence alignment editor and analysis program for Windowns 95/98/NT. Nucleic Acids Symp Ser. 1999;41:95–8.
Löytynoja A, Goldman N. An algorithm for progressive multiple alignment of sequences with insertions. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2005;102:10557–62.
Xia X, Lemey P. Assessing substitution saturation with DAMBE. In: Lemey P, Salemi M, Vandamme A-M, editors. The phylogenetic handbook: a practical approach to DNA and protein phylogeny. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2009. p. 615-630.
Posada D. jModelTest: phylogenetic model averaging. Mol Biol Evol. 2008;25(7):1253–6.
Drummond AJ, Rambaut A. BEAST: Bayesian evolutionary analysis by sampling trees. BMC Evol Biol. 2007;7:214.
Kass RE, Raftery AE. Bayes factors. J Am Stat Assoc. 1995;90:773–95.
Suchard MA, Weiss RE, Sinsheimer JS. Bayesian selection of continuous-time Markov chain evolutionary models. Mol Biol Evol. 2001;18:1001–13.
Paradis E, Bolker B, Claude J, Cuong HS, Desper R, Durand B, et al. APE: analyses of phylogenetics and evolution. R package; version 3.1-4; 2014.
Harmon L, Weir J, Brock C, Glor R, Challenger W, Hunt G, et al. Geiger: analysis of evolutionary diversification. R package; version 2.0.3; 2014.
Ree RH, Smith SA. Maximum likelihood inference of geographic range evolution by dispersal, local extinction, and cladogenesis. Syst Biol. 2008;57:4–14.
Center for International Earth Science Information Network (CIESIN), Columbia University, United Nations Food and Agriculture Programme (FAO), Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT). Gridded population of the World, Version 3 (GWP): Population Count Grid, Future Estimates. Palisades, NY: NASA Socioeconomic Data and Applications Center (SEDAC); 2005. http://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu. Accessed 15 October 2014.
Hijmans RJ. Raster: Geographic data analysis and modeling. R package version 2.2-31; 2014.
Bivand R, Keitt T, Rowlingson B. rgdal: bindings for the Geospatial Data Abstraction Library. R package; version 0.9-1; 2014.
Hijmans RJ, Phillips S, Leathwick J, Elith J. dismo: species distribution modeling. R package; version 0.9-3; 2013.
Genner MJ, Todd JA, Michel E, Erpenbeck D, Jimoh A, Joyce DA, et al. Amassing diversity in an ancient lake: evolution of a morphologically diverse parthenogenetic gastropod assemblage in Lake Malawi. Mol Ecol. 2007;16(3):517–30.
Mandahl-Barth G. The freshwater Mollusca of Lake Malawi. Revue de Zoologie et de Botanique Africaines. 1972;86:257–89.
Van Bocxlaer B, Salenbien W, Praet N, Verniers J. Stratigraphy and paleoenvironments of the early to middle Holocene Chipalamawamba Beds (Malawi Basin, Africa). Biogeosciences. 2012;9:4497–512.
Schultheiß R, Van Bocxlaer B, Riedel F, von Rintelen T, Albrecht C. Disjunct distributions of freshwater snails testify to a central role of the Congo system in shaping biogeographic patterns in Africa. BMC Evol Biol. 2014;14:42.
Glaubrecht M, Strong EE. Ancestry to an endemic radiation in Lake Tanganyika? Evolution of the viviparous gastropod Potadomoides Leloup, 1953 in the Congo River System (Caenogastropoda, Cerithioidea, Paludomidae). Biol J Linn Soc. 2007;92(2):367–401.
Kullander SO, Roberts TR. Out of Lake Tanganyika: endemic lake fishes inhabit rapids of the Lukuga River. Ichtyol Explor Freshwaters. 2011;22(4):355–76.
Salzburger W, Mack T, Verheyen E, Meyer A. Out of Tanganyika: genesis, explosive speciation, key-innovations and phylogeography of the haplochromine cichlid fishes. BMC Evol Biol. 2005;5:17.
Seegers L. The fishes of the Lake Rukwa drainage. Annales du Musée Royal de l'Afrique Centrale, Sciences Zoologiques. 1996;278:1–407.
Cohen AS, Van Bocxlaer B, Todd JA, McGlue M, Michel E, Nkotagu HN, et al. Quaternary ostracodes and molluscs from the Rukwa Basin (Tanzania) and their evolutionary and paleobiogeographic implications. Palaeogeogr, Palaeoclimatol, Palaeoecol. 2013;392:79–97.
Wilson AB, Glaubrecht M, Meyer A. Ancient lakes as evolutionary reservoirs: evidence from the thalassoid gastropods of Lake Tanganyika. Proc R Soc B Biol Sci. 2004;271:529–36.
Ndifon GT, Ukoli FMA. Ecology of freshwater snails in south-western Nigeria. I. Distribution and habitat preferences. Hydrobiologia. 1989;171(3):231–53.
Alin SR, Cohen AS, Bills R, Gashagaza MM, Michel E, Tiercelin JJ, et al. Effects of landscape disturbance on animal communities in Lake Tanganyika, East Africa. Conserv Biol. 1999;13:1017–33.
Eggermont H, Verschuren D. Impact of soil erosion in disturbed tributary drainages on the benthic invertebrate fauna of Lake Tanganyika, East Africa. Biol Conserv. 2003;113:99–109.
Cohen AS, Bills R, Cocquyt CZ, Caljon AG. The impact of sediment pollution on biodiversity in Lake Tanganyika. Conserv Biol. 1993;7:667–77.
Donohue I, Verheyen E, Irvine K. In situ experiments on the effects of increased sediment loads on littoral rocky shore communities in Lake Tanganyika, East Africa. Freshwat Biol. 2003;48:1603–16.
McIntyre PB, Michel E, France K, Rivers A, Hakizimana P, Cohen AS. Individual- and assemblage-level effects of anthropogenic sedimentation on snails in Lake Tanganyika. Conserv Biol. 2005;19(1):171–81.
Otu MK, Ramlal P, Wilkinson P, Hall RI, Hecky RE. Paleolimnological evidence of the effects of recent cultural eutrophication during the last 200 years in Lake Malawi, East Africa. J Great Lakes Res. 2011;37:61–74.
Pilsbry HA, Bequaert J. The aquatic molluscs of the Belgian Congo, with a geographical and ecological account of Congo malacology. Bull Am Mus Nat Hist N Y. 1927;53:69–602.
Strong EE, Colgan DJ, Healy JM, Lydeard C, Ponder WF, Glaubrecht M. Phylogeny of the gastropod superfamily Cerithioidea using morphology and molecules. Zool J Linn Soc. 2011;162:43–89.
Mooney HA, Cleland EE. The evolutionary impact of invasive species. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2001;98(10):5446–51.
The Congo Biodiversity Consortium supported fieldwork in the Congo Basin and the Official University of Ruwenzori (Vikandy S. Mambo, Meni Malikwicha) in Eastern Congo. Fieldwork support in the DRC was provided by Ernest Tambwe Lukosha. Daniel Engelhard, Thies Geertz and Roland Schultheiß collected samples in Uganda, the DRC and Rwanda. Thomas von Rintelen kindly provided collection data. Torsten Hauffe and Björn Stelbrink provided help with geographical modeling and phylogenetic inference, respectively. Constructive input on an earlier draft was provided by Jon Todd. The manuscript was reviewed independently by Axios Review; the handling editor Melania Cristescu and four anonymous referees provided many constructive suggestions that significantly improved the paper. Funding was received from the Flanders Research Foundation, the Belgian American Educational Foundation, a Peter Buck Fellowship of the Smithsonian Institution and an Alexander von Humboldt Fellowship to B.V.B., a Fellowship of the German Academic Exchange Service to J.-P.M.E., and DFG grants AL 1076/6-2, 7-1, 8-1 to C.A.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
BVB and CA conceived and designed the study. BVB, JPME, AK, and OWN performed fieldwork in Africa; BVB and CC performed molecular and morphological analyses; BVB performed geographic modeling. BVB led the writing of the paper. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Cycling conditions for polymerase chain reactions used to amplify gene fragments.
Results of ancestral range reconstructions with Lagrange at nodes in the ingroup.
Ecological data for localities where newly discovered invasive morphs of Melanoides tuberculata were found.
About this article
Cite this article
Van Bocxlaer, B., Clewing, C., Mongindo Etimosundja, JP. et al. Recurrent camouflaged invasions and dispersal of an Asian freshwater gastropod in tropical Africa. BMC Evol Biol 15, 33 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12862-015-0296-2
- Ancient Lakes Malawi and Tanganyika
- Congo River
- Melanoides tuberculata
- Ecosystem change
- Anthropogenic stressor
- Feedback mechanisms