Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison of key divergence times, taxa and markers in the pellonuline phylogeny between studies

From: Complete mitochondrial genomes and updated divergence time of the two freshwater clupeids endemic to Lake Tanganyika (Africa) suggest intralacustrine speciation

 

Divergence time estimate (MYA)

 

This study

Egan et al. 2018

Bloom and Lovejoy 2014

Wilson et al. 2008

Lavoué et al. 2013

Markers

PCGs

CYT-B, 16S, rag1, rag2, slc, zic1

16S, CYT-B, rag1, rag2

16S, 12S, CYT-B

PCGs, tRNAs, rRNAs

Number of taxa (excl. outgroup)

107

190

153

49

82

Number of sites (bp)

18,279

7135

5211

1049–1811

10,733

Node

     

Limnothrissa miodon—Stolothrissa tanganicae

3.64

[0.99–6.29]

3.91

[1.19–6.64]

6.61

[2.20–11.01]

7.6

[2.1–15.9]

-

LT sardines–

Potamothrissa obtusirostris

10.92

[6.37–15.48]

10.04

[5.62–14.47]

23.35

[16.37–30.33]

–

–

LT sardines–

other pellonulines

–

–

–

27

[25.0–53.3]

–

Incursion 1: pellonulines–other clupeids

43.71

[31.79–55.63]1

34.30

[25.56–43.03]1

47.58

[35.68–59.47]1

37

[25.0–53.3]2

46.05

[33.38–58.71]1

Incursion 2: Gilchristella–Sauvagella

–

25.00

[13.39–36.61]

33.92

[18.94–48.90]

20

[7.5–34.4]

–

Ehiravini–Pellonulini

64.57

[50.17–78.97]

70.13

[59.74–83.44]

98.24

[85.02–111.46]

48

[34.0–66.2]

89.02

[80.97–97.08]

  1. Numbers between square brackets indicate 95% credibility intervals. Divergence times from our study were estimated in BEAST, those from other studies were directly reported or extracted from time-calibrated trees using WebPlotDigitizer. Markers indicated in bold were available for both Stolothrissa tanganicae and Limnothrissa miodon. PCGs = all mitochondrial protein coding genes, CYT-B = cytochrome B, 16S = 16S rRNA, 12S = 12S rRNA. 1Split Pellonulini – Ethmalosa fimbriata. 2Split Pellonulini—other clupeids (E. fimbriata not included in the study)