PBR | Non-PBR | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Comparisons | N | dN(±SE) | dS(±SE) | dN/dS | z-test | dN(±SE) | dS(±SE) | dN/dS | z-test |
Brown et al.[44] | |||||||||
Neso01-23 | 23 | 0.377 (±0.146) | 0.236 (±0.161) | 1.60 | n.s. (0.54) | 0.133 (±0.029) | 0.114 (±0.051) | 1.17 | n.s. (0.74) |
Neso01-21 ǂ | 21 | 0.372 (±0.142) | 0.234 (±0.174) | 1.59 | n.s. (0.59) | 0.090 (±0.022) | 0.097 (±0.047) | 0.93 | n.s. (0.90) |
Group1 | 2 | 0.031 (±0.031) | 0.000 (±0.000) | n/a | n.s. (0.33) | 0.011 (±0.011) | 0.039 (±0.040) | 0.28 | n.s. (0.51) |
Group2 | 15 | 0.009 (±0.006) | 0.000 (±0.000) | n/a | n.s. (0.16) | 0.028 (±0.007) | 0.042 (±0.030) | 0.67 | n.s. (0.68) |
Group3 | 6 | 0.073 (±0.033) | 0.036 (±0.049) | 2.03 | n.s. (0.51) | 0.023 (±0.010) | 0.014 (±0.014) | 1.64 | n.s. (0.62) |
Inaccessible ǂ | 19 | 0.361 (±0.133) | 0.222 (±0.149) | 1.63 | n.s. (0.53) | 0.135 (±0.026) | 0.115 (±0.050) | 1.17 | n.s. (0.74) |
Nightingale ǂ | 12 | 0.420 (±0.151) | 0.281 (±0.192) | 1.49 | n.s. (0.60) | 0.166 (±0.034) | 0.118 (±0.055) | 1.41 | n.s. (0.43) |
Tristan da Cunha ǂ | 21 | 0.377 (±0.146) | 0.236 (±0.161) | 1.60 | n.s. (0.54) | 0.133 (±0.029) | 0.114 (±0.051) | 1.17 | n.s. (0.74) |
Rowettia goughensis | 6 | 0.486 (±0.188) | 0.351 (±0.246) | 2.59 | n.s. (0.70) | 0.194 (±0.040) | 0.135 (±0.063) | 1.44 | n.s. (0.40) |
Tong et al.[45] | |||||||||
Neso01-23 | 23 | 0.230 (±0.090) | 0.125 (±0.159) | 1.84 | n.s. (0.61) | 0.174 (±0.033) | 0.143 (±0.051) | 1.22 | n.s. (0.61) |
Neso01-21 ǂ | 21 | 0.100 (±0.054) | 0.090 (±0.147) | 0.11 | n.s. (0.96) | 0.151 (±0.032) | 0.135 (±0.055) | 1.12 | n.s. (0.79) |
Group1 | 2 | 0.053 (±0.052) | 0.000 (±0.000) | n/a | n.s. (0.33) | 0.053 (±0.053) | 0.000 (±0.000) | n/a | n.s. (0.32) |
Group2 | 15 | 0.018 (±0.019) | 0.000 (±0.000) | n/a | n.s. (0.38) | 0.024 (±0.006) | 0.033 (±0.025) | 0.73 | n.s. (0.73) |
Group3 | 6 | 0.033 (±0.022) | 0.000 (±0.000) | n/a | n.s. (0.14) | 0.036 (±0.013) | 0.024 (±0.017) | 1.50 | n.s. (0.58) |
Inaccessible ǂ | 19 | 0.240 (±0.091) | 0.126 (±0.165) | 1.90 | n.s. (0.57) | 0.171 (±0.032) | 0.139 (±0.049) | 1.13 | n.s. (0.59) |
Nightingale ǂ | 12 | 0.306 (±0.124) | 0.152 (±0.189) | 2.01 | n.s. (0.54) | 0.204 (±0.038) | 0.152 (±0.058) | 1.34 | n.s. (0.44) |
Tristan da Cunha ǂ | 21 | 0.230 (±0.090) | 0.125 (±0.159) | 1.84 | n.s. (0.61) | 0.174 (±0.033) | 0.143 (±0.051) | 1.22 | n.s. (0.61) |
Rowettia goughensis | 6 | 0.334 (±0.123) | 0.163 (±0.189) | 2.05 | n.s. (0.52) | 0.238 (±0.045) | 0.186 (±0.069) | 1.28 | n.s. (0.49) |
New Zealand robin | 41 | 0.339 (±0.078) | 0.094 (±0.059) | 3.6 | <0.005 | 0.076 (±0.019) | 0.039 (±0.013) | 1.95 | n.s. |
Chatham Island robin | 4 | 0.373 (±0.086) | 0.135 (±0.078) | 2.76 | <0.05 | 0.099 (±0.024) | 0.020 (±0.014) | 5.05 | <0.005 |
Hawaiian honeycreepers | 51 | 0.341 (±0.103) | 0.076 (±0.095) | 4.49 | <0.001 | 0.121 (±0.038) | 0.092 (±0.053) | 1.32 | n.s. |
Common yellowthroat | 39 | 0.608 (±0.120) | 0.211 (±0.111) | 2.88 | <0.05 | 0.135 (±0.034) | 0.137 (±0.034) | 0.99 | n.s. |
House sparrow* | 12 | 0.470 (±0.109) | 0.123 (±0.095) | 3.82 | <0.0001 | 0.203 (±0.047) | 0.200 (±0.051) | 1.02 | n.s. |